IDShield Identity Theft Protection
We tested IDShield and vetted its plans, packages, and pricing so that you don’t have to
- Access to licensed Private Investigators
- Credit freeze and fraud alert features
- Up to $1 million in ID theft restoration
Identity monitoring services can be a bit hard to tell apart since they all have similar features, so pricing is always a huge factor in our purchasing decision. IDShield, a product of the legal company LegalShield, definitely impressed us when it came to its actual services, but was it worth its price? On this page, we’ll discuss IDShield’s pricing, how it compares to competitors on the market, and whether or not it’s worth it.
|Number of credit bureaus monitored||Monthly Cost|
IDShield Subscription Options
IDShield made it as simple as possible for us when it came to pricing, with plans for individuals and families, i.e two adults and up to 10 children. With both individual and family plans, we had two tiers to choose from. One tier covered credit monitoring from TransUnion only, and the other tier covered credit monitoring from all three bureaus, tacking on Equifax and Experian.
|Subscription information||IDShield Individual||IDShield Three-Bureau Individual||IDShield Family||IDShield Three-Bureau Family|
|Maximum number of users||1||1||2 adults, 10 children||2 adults, 10 children|
|Credit bureaus monitored||TransUnion||Equifax, Experian, TransUnion||TransUnion||Equifax, Experian, TransUnion|
For plans that monitored TransUnion alone, the price was only $14.95 a month for individuals and $29.95 a month for families. These prices are super reasonable, especially for families; compare that to if you had to buy individual subscriptions for 12 people, the family plan could save $149.45 a month.
Tip: We recommend signing up for credit monitoring from all three credit bureaus for the most comprehensive coverage; it’s worth the extra $5 a month.
Something that disappointed us a bit was the fact that IDShield didn’t provide discounted options if we signed up for a year or longer, something that many other identity monitoring companies do. However, given its affordable prices, we think that IDShield is right where it should be when it comes to costs. And when we consider the fact that the average victim of identity theft pays $1,100 out of pocket,1 IDShield could actually pay for itself in the event that someone steals our identity.
If you haven’t read our IDShield review, after testing it out for ourselves, we definitely think it’s a worthwhile investment in terms of features. Here’s what makes IDShield worth the money, in our opinion:
- Affordability: An individual plan with credit monitoring from TransUnion costs only $14.95 a month, or $5 more per month with monitoring from all three bureaus.
- Comprehensive identity monitoring: IDShield covered everything from our Social Security numbers to change of address registries, making sure our personally identifiable information stayed safe from identity thieves.
- Free trial: IDShield gave us a 30-day free trial, which comes with all of its subscription options.
- Identity theft insurance: Even the most comprehensive monitoring can’t prevent identity theft 100%, so if anyone ever steals our identities, we would get up to $1 million back in reimbursement costs, the industry standard.
What Does IDShield Cover?
We’ve talked a lot about dollars and cents, but we also want to share exactly what we got with a subscription from IDShield. More specifically, we want to talk about what IDShield’s identity and credit monitoring included.
- Credit scores and reports: While the lower-tier plans only gave us credit scores and reports from TransUnion, the upper-tier plans gave us credit scores and reports from all three bureaus, TransUnion, Equifax and Experian. This was the only thing that differed between the subscriptions; the rest of the features were the same throughout all the plans.
- Social media: IDShield scanned our social media accounts (specifically Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter and Instagram) for any posts and settings that could compromise our privacy. It also provided suggestions on how we can make our online profiles more private, such as by adjusting our privacy settings.
- Sex offender registries: Of course, we want to know if we turned up on a sex offender registry, which IDShield monitored. It also told us if there were sex offenders living in our neighborhood, which helped us to stay safe offline as well.
- Address changes: While we always report to the U.S.P.S if we move and need a change of address, IDShield monitors this database constantly, making sure no one else changes our records so that we’d keep receiving our mail and packages.
- Telecom: In the same vein, IDShield made sure that no one tapped into and redirected our phone numbers. Our credit card companies send one-time passcodes to our phone numbers, so this type of monitoring was crucial.
- Dark web: Most identity monitoring services, including IDShield, scan the dark web to make sure our credentials stay off of forums and sites that buy or sell stolen identities.
- Public and court records: IDShield made sure that our data didn’t appear in the United States’ 78 billion public records and 250 million court records. It made sure that criminals weren’t using our names to commit crimes, even as small as parking violations.
- PayDay loans: Trying to use our information to take out a quick loan? Not so fast. IDShield scanned not only PayDay loans but also online and rent-to-own loans for our information.
- High-risk applications: IDShield monitored bank accounts for our information, making sure that only we were opening new accounts under our names.
- Identity theft insurance: If someone were to steal our identities, a possibility even with an identity monitoring service, we would receive up to $1 million in reimbursements.
- Lost wallet support: A lost wallet can be a stressful thing, but it’s even more stressful if you consider how much of your personal information it contains on top of your cash and credit cards. Fortunately, IDShield’s investigators will help us out, making sure our identities stay safe even if we lose our wallets.
Those are the basic features we expect of any identity monitoring service, but IDShield takes it several steps further with some features we see either rarely or never:
- Solicitation reduction: When we paid for IDShield, we saw a significant reduction in the amount of junk mail we received as well as the number of telemarketing calls we got. This is a pretty unique feature; only IdentityForce has something comparable, to our knowledge.
The More You Know: The average American gets 41 pounds of junk mail a year, half of which is never opened.2 But junk mail could also be a catalyst for identity theft if someone steals it to attain your personal information, so look for a service that reduces the amount of junk mail in your mailbox.
- Data broker deletion: Another rare feature of IDShield is the fact that it scanned websites like Whitepages for our personal information and had them delete it. This prevented advertisers from getting our personal information.
- Protection cyberbullying: Anti-bullying protection is only available with IDShield’s family plans. The sad fact is that 42% of children have been bullied online,3 but with IDShield, parents can learn about cyberbullying sooner and put a stop to it. Again, this feature is rare. Aside from IDShield, we’ve seen it in our review of Identity Guard, which has been an overall favorite in identity theft protection services for several years running.
- Reputation management: When you’re applying for a job or even dating someone new, you want to make sure that your web presence is squeaky clean. IDShield helped us out with that, letting us know if there were any offensive comments or NSFW pictures that we should take down.
- Medical data reports: For the most protection, IDShield even scanned medical data reports for fraudulent or false information, keeping our health records in check.
Does IDShield Have A Free Trial?
As we’ve mentioned earlier, one of our favorite features was IDShield’s free 30-day trial that came with all of its subscriptions. This is actually common with identity theft protection services, but whenever we get something for free, we’re always grateful. IDShield’s free trial means that when we signed up for an account, the company didn’t charge us until 30 days later. But if we cancelled before that time came, IDShield wouldn’t have charged us at all.
For comparison’s sake, our overall favorite Identity Guard plan comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee in lieu of an Identity Guard free trial. Alternatively, LifeLock’s 30-day free trial is a great way to test out the service, though it’s worth mentioning that LifeLock’s past data breaches and class-action lawsuits make us a bit wary of LifeLock as a brand.
As we test out the top-rated identity monitoring services of this year, we end up having to cancel a lot of our subscriptions, the experience of which varies greatly from company to company. But with IDShield’s free trial, it was easy to cancel without paying anything at all. Cancelling customers could either call IDShield directly or email the support team at email@example.com. However, note that until we received written notice back that our cancellation went through, we were still active members, so it didn’t happen immediately.
Overall, we’re enthusiastic about IDShield as our identity theft protection, and the prices are certainly right, especially for folks who are looking for the best identity theft protection for the whole family. Although we wish that the company had discounted options for longer term-lengths, we did appreciate the fact that we could cancel easily at any time without running into cancellation fees, and the 30 day risk-free trial didn’t hurt either.
Is IDShield better than LifeLock?
In our opinion and based on our testing, LifeLock is better than IDShield. LifeLock offers better digital security, as some of its plans include antivirus protection as well. Since cybercriminals use malware to steal personal information, we prefer having antivirus protection on top of identity theft protection.
What is IDShield?
IDShield is an identity monitoring service from the company LegalShield, which provides legal services. Depending on the plan, IDShield can monitor credit scores and reports from all three major credit-reporting bureaus in the United States, along with the user’s Social Security number, public records, court records, and other areas of criminal concern. IDShield was founded by Harland Stonecipher and is based in Oklahoma.
What does IDShield cover?
IDShield has comprehensive coverage for identity monitoring, including credit scores and reports, Social Security numbers, the dark web, public records, court records, PayDay loans, usernames and passwords, high-risk applications, address changes filed with the United States Postal Service, sex offender registries, phone records, and social media. Its services also reduce the amount of junk mail a user gets, delete data brokers and even cover medical data reports and lost wallets. If a user’s identity is stolen, IDShield could cover them for up to $1 million in reimbursements.
How do I cancel my IDShield account?
To cancel IDShield, either call customer support at 800-654-7757 or email them at firstname.lastname@example.org. But note that until the user receives official confirmation of cancellation, they’re still an active and paying member.
What identity theft protection is best?
The best identity theft protection, based on our extensive testing and knowledge of digital security, are IdentityGuard, IdentityIQ, LifeLock, IdentityForce, ID Watchdog, Experian IdentityWorks, Aura, Credit Sesame, PrivacyGuard, Zander Insurance, IDShield, and IDnotify.
Javelin Strategy. (2021). 2021 Identity Fraud Study: Shifting Angles.
Sightline Institute. (2007). Junk Mail Box: Stopping Paper Waste. sightline.org/2007/12/31/junk-mail-box-stopping-paper-waste/
i-Safe. Retrieved 2020, July 7. Cyber Bullying: Statistics and Tips.